Imjomat — How can an annotation buyer judge a pilot batch?
An illustrative Mirror scenario for data annotation. A buyer asking for an accuracy number may actually need to know who decides a disputed label. Agreement on routine examples gives little guidance when a rare class changes how the trained model will be evaluated.
THE SHORT ANSWER
A buyer can judge a labeling pilot by reviewing how disagreements are resolved as well as how often reviewers agree. A well-chosen borderline item makes otherwise hidden differences in the labeling instructions visible.
What to put in the research brief
Prepare a short labeling guide, a synthetic sample with borderline cases and a proposed review queue. Specify the buyer's acceptance criteria. Avoid using confidential training examples to demonstrate the procurement workflow.
The decision to rehearse in Mirror
Ask Mirror to compare a volume-based proposal with a pilot that includes adjudication. Give the ML lead, procurement reviewer and annotation supervisor the same ambiguous item. Trace what happens when the written guideline supports two readings.
Reading the Imjomat card
The homepage card displays 3.4k b2b reactions and 8 buyer personas. These are illustrative figures used in the card design. Observations from a live pilot would need their own sample, time period and measurement method.
How to test the idea in practice
Have two reviewers independently label a held-out sample, then document the reasoning behind disagreements. Record the cost of clarification and rework as well as overall agreement before negotiating a larger batch.
Common questions
Why include difficult examples in an annotation pilot?
A random small batch can omit the very cases that drive review effort. Report performance on a representative sample and examine borderline items separately so the challenge set does not distort the overall rate.
Put the questions to work.
Explore a scenario using your own source material in Mirror.
Open Mirror ↗View plans